The High Court Gets It Right: Buck v. Stephens

 

As I discussed in a previous blog the United States Supreme Court was reviewing the case of Duane Buck, an inmate on Texas death row.  The issue was whether Buck should receive a new sentencing hearing because the jurors heard testimony from a (defense!) expert witness that the defendant was more likely to commit violent crimes and pose a future danger because he is black.  I mentioned in the earlier post that in my humble opinion, this was an unconscionable piece of testimony from the defense expert.  Someone’s race should never be part of the equation when a jury determines if a defendant should live or die.

Well, my humble opinion or not, the Supreme Court agreed.  They recently ruled 6-2 in Duane Buck’s favor and tossed out the death penalty sentence previously rendered.  Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the majority opinion and in it, likened the race-based testimony of the expert to a “toxin”, which can still be “deadly in small doses”.  It is heartening to know that at least in this case, justice was done.

Buck’s conviction still stands, but he will have the chance to have another punishment hearing in front of a new jury.  As I stated before, if he deserves death, so be it, but the let jury who makes that choice be one who judges him for what he did, and not just for who he was born as.

Advertisements

Author: brunnerdefenseblog

I have ten years of prosecution experience as an Assistant District Attorney in Polk and Williamson Counties, with over three years' experience as the First Assistant District Attorney. I also have six years of criminal defense experience, handling cases throughout Central Texas. I graduated from Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas, in 1993 with a B.A. in Psychology, and from Southern Methodist University School of Law in Dallas, Texas, in 1997.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s